Categories
GIS Technology

Mapping Hacks – a challenge ?

Jo Walsh reports on the Mapping Hacks website on the debate I attended at the society of cartographers conference on public access to data, and comments that the investments made on GPS and Photogrammetry by the OS is “viably unnecessary, easily outsourceable techno-toys.”

OK Jo – why don’t you try and capture some data to the OS specification the details are here (3mb pdf), without access to the ‘toys’ of the trade.

As I have noted before I think there is a place for open geodata and await developments with interest, but this is a case of somebody without a true understanding of the professional geographic information industry pushing an agenda despite the facts.

I would have liked to post this challenge on the mapping hacks website, but you can’t leave comments…

Categories
Technology Thoughts

If you go down to the tube today…

You had better not take your laptop…

Like many of my fellow tech workers in London, I carry my powerbook plus other kit in a rucksack and following the events of 7/7 have joked about how we must appear to others.

This is no longer a joking matter however and the extent to which the “security services’ are using the terrible events of July to restrict personal liberty was reported in todays Guardian (pdf). David Mery had a night out from hell after making the mistake of carrying a laptop on the tube in his rucksack and owning the type of equipment we all take for granted at home, you know scary stuff like usb hubs, gps receivers and maps !

We all want to be kept safe, but not to the extent that we all become suspects of CCTV checklists, you defeat terrorists using intelligence and politically removing their motivation – not alienating the general population.

Written and submitted from home, using my home 802.11 network.

Categories
GIS Thoughts

Where is the innovation

Yesterday, the OS ran the first terrafutures event, a one day workshop to try and bring together scientists of all types, sociologists and IT experts to look into the future and spot the trends in technology and society that will impact on the GI industry.

Some of the key findings included the future pervasivness of network connectivity and the ability of almost everything to be located across these networks in real time. At the same time the focus of economic activity globally is shifting eastward with North America and Europe becoming displaced by India and China, which will result in large new potential markets and well trained, skilled GI professional becoming available at costs a fraction of those today.

How is the traditional GI industry responding to these changes.. well not very fast, for the past 20 years you could argue that the innovation which has taken place has been a result of technology changes in mainstream IT, exploiting developments such as the web and object relational databases. Recent innovations again have come when mainstream IT developments have been adopted for use in geographical applications, Google Maps is the application of AJAX programming to mapping, but this time the traditional GI industry has been bypassed.

The area where GI innovation could make a real difference in the next few years, is also a computer science problem, but one in which GI is playing a leading role – the semantic web.

The semantic web a phrase coined by Tim Berners Lee, the “Father of the Web” relates to an “upgrade” to todays web, where more structured meaningful data is published and subscribed to by web based applications – todays web is human readable and semantic web is machine readable.

We are beginning to see the first semantic web applications which understand geography, recognising place-names in web published documents. This sounds easy but the problem in recognising when ‘Reading” means a place, rather than what you do with a newspaper is a difficult one. For GI this needs the development of more formal ways of describing geographical features and they relationships – the development of geographical ontologies.

There are many challenges ahead for the GI industry, although operationally in many areas the industry has reached maturity, there are still many questions that need to be answered.. yesterdays event was a fantastic opportunity for us GI guys to look out of the silo and take a bearing on the potential direction of our future.

Watch this space over the next week or so, I hope to bring news of our plans to podcast some of the terrafutures presentations, and congratulations to all involved in organising the first of what I hope is a series of similar meetings.

Categories
GIS

Coming soon – the GPS for the iPod generation

Recently announced the Garmin Nüvi is a GPS device clearly inspired by the success of the iPod. The Nüvi as well as a GPS routefinder is also an MP3 player with pda like functionality including a world clock, currency converter, image viewer and add-on travel & language guide software.

Looks like the Tom-Tom has some competition…

Written and submitted from home, using my home 802.11 network.

Categories
GIS Thoughts

Peer to Peer Geodata anyone ?

I have just come across geoTorrent.org a website offering links to geodata sets hosted using the bit-torent peer to peer network protocol. The idea of distributing large geodata datasets as small chucks is quite appealing and I have no doubt that when open geodata becomes more mature – this will be the obvious mechanism of supply. One of the aspects of the age of broadband internet often overlooked is that most ISP’s impose some sort of bandwidth limit, which is easily broken hosting large geodata libraries – bit-torent’s architecture neatly gets around this problem.

But what about commercial data providers.. despite all the advantages there is a big problem – peer to peer means piracy in many minds, an unfortunate perception ,but one that needs to be disproved if the GI industry is to really make use of a valuable technology.

Written and submitted from home, using my home 802.11 network.

Categories
Technology

Beauty and the beast

So after months of speculation and delayed launch dates, the i-tunes phone is released – and its a lemon !
An ugly old Motorola phone, the MotoROKR phone does not allow you to download music via a mobile network, you cannot sync songs using bluetooth and it has a Motorola user interface – remember no two Motorola phones have the same UI !!

Even during Steves Jobs demo, he came unstuck trying to use it.

The new iPod nano of the other hand is just THE thing to lust after, a very small flash-memory based iPod photo – I bought mine today at the Apple Store in London and I can’t stop just picking it up and playing with it – the design is just magical !!

If anyone every needed a lesson in the importance of industrial design this is it – I expect the iPod to continue to dominate the market, everybody will want a nano, and the ROKR will disappear.

Categories
GIS Thoughts

First Where 2.0 Podcast online

Back at the end of June, the O’Reilly media Where 2.0 conference took place in San Francisco and saw presentations from Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo amongst others on their perspective of the expanding mainstream GI market. The first audio recording from this conference is now available online at the ITConversations website.

The Past and Future of Mapping is a presentation by David Rumsey a well known map collector and historian who spends 30 minutes looking at the major historical developments in cartography and points out that we are revisiting many of the techniques of the past with the latest generation of web mapping sites. This is a very interest presentation well worth listening to.

I’m just disappointed with a comment David makes at the end of the podcast comparing the situation in the US where USGS makes available geodata at no change, with the OS policy of licensing geodata to fund its operations.

David comments, as do many, that OS geodata should be free – well perhaps he would like to send us all a copy of his book Cartographica Extraordinaire: The Historical Map Transformed” for free rather than charging $80 ? – but then again maybe he needs to recover the publishing costs of the book and make a little profit to expand his collection ?

Unlike the USGS the OS is not funded by the taxpayer, and like David the OS needs to cover its costs.

Written and submitted from home, using my home 802.11 network.

Categories
GIS Technology

The State of the GI Nation

David Sonnen captures very well the current “State of the Nation” as far as the GI industry is concerned in his Directions Magazine article Spatial Information Management (SIM) – Then, Now, Next . I think David is right to see the disruptive effect of “big guys” on the established GI industry – funny to think of Microsoft as disruptive :-), and the move towards a mainstream SOA future for the industry.

But I think he may be missing the impact of what I would call the underground GI industry of google map hackers and the open geodata movement – here real innovation is happening. Look at how fast new datasets, OK of variable quality, appeared to track the progress of the Hurricane Katrina disaster – in some cases as the most up to date source of information.

Written and submitted from Cambridge, using a Starbucks T-Mobile 802.11 network.

Categories
Thoughts

Happy Holidays

OK so I have surrived about 10 days without the internet, but the draw of the internet cafe was too much. So I find myself having a great cup of the best coffee portugal can provide while checking my email, and having a chat to a Aussie girl about the cricket. Amazing places internet cafes – the modern post restante!

Categories
Thoughts

Imperial madness !!

A sad reflection on that part of the British character that is so resistant to change… City of York council are called to account reports the BBC for using metric measurements on footpath markers.

It seems that it is only the UK and the United States that continue to use miles and feet as measure of distance, and in the UK the situation is really confused, we buy fuel by the litre, measure distance using miles, and buy frozen food by the kilo !!

As someone taught only metric measurements 30 years ago in a UK school, I often wonder if we will ever join the rest of the world ?

BTW OS maps have been metric since the mid 1960’s